Vibe coded apps give me the ick

I have the privilege of going to a very nice gym. I like working out and the gym is one of the few things that I will spend money on. If that’s not your thing I get it, but it’s my thing. A couple of months ago my gym rolled out a “members only app”. This app would allow you to track your lifts, save progress pictures, interact with your trainer (which had previously been conducted over email), see your achievements, and have supplementary workout regimens. All in all, this was a business endeavor that makes sense from an engagement, tracking, convenience, and overall gym-experience perspective. Many other gyms have apps (Equinox, Planet Fitness) so why not my gym? I took a look at the web app and immediately saw the tell-tale signs of a vibe-coded app™. Yes, it had the generic artifacts ("Happy-path-only" flows, overuse of emojis), the slightly human UX patterns (AKA using it kind of made sense), and it just looked like a Frankenstein version of other apps you know that you might have even paid for in the past. My fears were confirmed when I talked to the owner of the gym and they bragged to me that they had built the app in 5 hours. At this point I felt unreasonably angry. "How could they do this to me?" This blog post is meant to explore that anger. Let me start this diatribe by saying that I am a massive hypocrite. Like many people in the world I “vibe-code” to my hearts content. One might even go as far to say that I was one of the original vibe-coders in early 2023. I am an early adopter of all things AI and it was when I found that I could point an LLM at some code I had written and make it into an actual working thing that I knew I would never go back to writing code by hand. This was pre-Claude Code and even then I knew that these tools were magic. Fast forward a couple years and I had all but burnt out on vibe-coding things. I disconnected a lot of my tools and discontinued many of the apps I had been building and maintaining for people around the world that were powered, in large part, by AI. I can’t tell you exactly where I lost my love for the space of building, but my general hypothesis is that we love the things that we toil on and I was not toiling on interesting technical challenges anymore. I had moved from a builder to "how can I get people to use my thing", but "my thing" was something that few people wanted. I was buying into an old version of building software, and I had to accept that things had changed. This extends to development of projects that "amateurs" (or people who don’t have a lot of time to build things) using AI to build their own projects. All of a sudden, the cost to create was at an all time low, but bad apps and websites were at an all time high. I was inundated with new things and I got tired. By the end of 2025, I was burnt out on all things AI. But, I digress, why was I having such a visceral reaction to an app that a small business owner built? Well I think it comes down to a few things: 1. I spent my career up to that point spending weeks/months/years toiling over apps and software and this person had built a serviceable product in 5 hours and I was mad and jealous. Many frustrations can be boiled down to being mad and/or jealous and I was that/both. 2. On the other hand, 5 hours is not really enough time to make a good… anything, and I detest things that don’t have love and thought behind them. Furthermore, I worry about putting identifying information into applications that aren't secure (or that I don't perceive as secure), so I opted out of engaging with the app. 3. Building apps is an old model of technology masquerading in modern day as something that "needs" to exist simply because "that's the way it's been". Apps are the things of the past (or feel like they are going that way) and I was expected to engage with something old instead of playing with something new. I feel this way about a lot of technology right now. We need to move to new paradigms but we are in a transitionary phase and that's difficult. 4. I was mad that I had put so many of my own apps out there in the past that were half baked and, facing this app, I understood why users may have been put off by the things I built (spoiler alert: my product didn't solve a major pain point). 5. Fitness apps make me mad. I’ve spent years trying to think of cool things to do around fitness and I still haven’t figured it out. 6. I have a general discontent where all things are going with tech. I don't know what's next, but this Frankenstein-era of tech we in right now is not fun and I have lost all trust of most applications. Now, it’s easy for me to sit here and talk about the things I don’t like about this app. Writing this all out has helped me figure out why I was frustrated, but it hasn’t brought me that much closer to providing an alternative. If I had to provide feedback to them though, it would be this: 1. Go all in on the tech and focus on making an awesome experience that is tailored and specific to what you do as an organization. This, to me, requires deep thought around why an app exists, what people are missing from their current experience, and a reason to engage with the app outside of it just being an extension of the gym. Treat it like a real, honest-to-god product, and not just something that has to exist because apps are apps are apps and they MUST exist. 2. Go all in on not using technology (my preference). I personally have enough technology in my life, and when I do bring in new technology its either cause I have to (work) or because it solves a very very deep problem for me (ex: Surfline allows me to see what the waves look like at this very second and a guesstimation of what they will be tomorrow or a week from now, which helps with planning). I want stripped back experiences in my life and I imagine most other people do too. In this instance, I would want the gym to keep track of the numbers for me, put them into an excel sheet, give me a challenge workout to do on a printed out piece of paper. Make me feel like I am am special (isn't that what we all want anyway). I care deeply about building things that make people feel good, I just feel like most of the things built these days make people feel bad, and thats a bummer. Rule to follow when building: Less technology, more making people feel special.